Collectible Toys

Discover a fantastic selection of vintage toys from beloved brands like Star Wars, Marvel, Fisher Price, and more. From Disney pins to collectible toys from your childhood, our selection will have you feeling nostalgic. Enjoy our hard-to-find pieces and stock up on memories right here!

421 results
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney Pirates of the Caribbean - Skull and Crossbones w/ Hidden Mickey Pin 2006
$9.00
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Wounded Highlander Metal Miniature Figurine On Bench (Possibly Britains)
$9.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Vintage Harry Potter Flying On Broom With Golden Snitch Action Figurine 2001
$5.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Vintage Waterloo Regiment Napoleonic War Toy Figurine - Possible Marx Reissue
$7.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Shere Khan Tiger The Jungle Book Disney Pin - From Villain Starter Set - 2005
$10.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys Thomas Livingston WWII British Soldiers Warriors Of The World 1960s
$10.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney Magical Musical Moments Quasimodo - I'm Gonna Love You Pin From 2002
$14.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Harry Potter Vintage Action Figure 2001 Sorcerers Stone Collectible Toy In Black Robes
$7.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Painted Napoleonic British Foot Artillery Miniature With Limber
$9.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Harry Potter Cast A Spell Vintage Toy With Wand & Flame Accessories From 2002
$7.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney's All Star Music Resort Collectible Pin From 2000
$17.99
in your cart
1 in stock
2.0 lb
Star Wars Episode 1 Clash Of The Lightsabers Card Game 1999 W/ Pewter Figures
$10.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney Mickey & Minnie Salute Memorial Day Limited Edition Pin 2008
$12.49
in your cart
1 in stock
0.63 lb
Star Trek TNG Geordi La Forge Action Figure With Accessories By Playmates 1992
$9.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney - Happy Mother's Day Fairy Godmother from Cinderella LE 2000 Pin 2007
$22.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys Jim Palozzo WWII US Combat Soldier Warriors Of The World 1960s
$10.49
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Vintage MC Toys Ferrari F40 Diecast Model Car 1:39 Scale Red With Opening Doors
$9.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.63 lb
Star Trek The Next Generation The Borg Action Figure Collectible - 1993
$8.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Vintage Trans AM Turbo 1/46 Scale Model Diecast Toy Car Collectible Black 1980s
$8.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys British Soldier Revolutionary War Warriors Of The World Reissue 1970s
$9.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys Gatt Random Confederate Soldier Warriors Of The World 1960s
$10.49
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney Mickey - Kali River Rapids - Featured Attraction Animal Kingdom Pin 2008
$24.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Lledo Chevron 1939 Chevrolet Pickup Standard Oil Refinery No. 21 Die-Cast Model
$7.99
in your cart
1 in stock
1.0 lb
Disney Villains Chernabog Pewter Fantasia Vintage Collectible Figurine 1997
$39.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys Bernal Veramendi Mexican War Soldier Warriors Of The World 1960s
$10.49
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disneyland - Sleeping Beauty Castle - Tinker Bell & Mickey Mouse 2008 Pin
$14.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Marx Toys Eric The Red Viking Warriors Of The World Collectible Figurine 1960s
$10.49
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Vintage 1999 Topps Star Wars Episode I Widevision Sticker Cards (incomplete set)
$10.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.5 lb
Zee Toys Red 56 T-Bird Diecast Model Car 1/40 Scale Vintage Collectible Toy 1980
$12.99
in your cart
1 in stock
0.25 lb
Disney Princess Crown - Pink with Jewels Collectible Pin from 2006
$12.99
in your cart
421 results